Monday, November 05, 2018

Why doesn't Facebook simply filter out politics?

As the adage goes, don’t discuss politics or religion at the dinner table. Facebook’s genesis was for friends and family to share what was going on in their lives. Yet over the past couple of years, many Facebook newsfeeds have turned into “Trumpbook,” with a stream of outrage-focused political posts fueling Facebook interactions, especially during election cycles.

Facebook first claimed that its fake news issue was “crazy”, then repeatedly stated that their algorithm could discern fake news, and has since changed its tune — it has a war room where armies of contractors analyze ads and posts for validity.

But with recent advancements in machine learning, it is now possible to algorithmically filter out political news and advertisements using off-the-shelf machine learning algorithms. Topic categorization algorithms have been successfully identifying content for years and have become increasingly sophisticated and turnkey. The realistic goal here should be to offer an option to filter out most political posts to avoid a problem called “overfitting” which would also filter out non-political posts. There is even a free Google Chrome extension that already filters out politics.

So given these advancements, why doesn’t Facebook offer an option to filter out political posts?

Our circle of “friends” has expanded

The first reason is that because our Facebook social networks have expanded far beyond actual friends and now encompass casual acquaintances, people are sharing fewer and fewer posts that are meaningful and personal. Posts have devolved into prompted interactions, with “tell me how you met me” chain letters, fundraisers, personality quiz results, fake events, birthday posts, and restaurant recommendations. People are increasingly sharing drivel.

Zuckerberg’s law of social sharing, which said people would double their sharing every year, started turning in 2016 and only accelerated as Facebook users have run out of things to post about and begin to worry about privacy. Attempts to get people to post live video to spice it up a bit did not get traction. One interesting point of traction is Facebook Memories where people can recycle older, more interesting posts.

But in the end, Facebook is a media company that needs to capture attention, and media has to be interesting to do that. People’s lives are generally repetitive and now that we’re in the tenth season of everybody's personal reality show, politics are taking a role by filling that gap.

Facebook needs the political traffic and advertising

A second reason is that Facebook needs the political traffic and advertising. Facebook has to maintain the news gravytrain until something else can make up for the traffic. The small tweaks that Facebook made in Q1 to promote meaningful social interactions and wellbeing over news posts led to a big dropoff in pageviews, culminating with a massive Q2 slowdown causing the largest stock market loss in history.

Meaningful social interactions now seem to include interactions about politics, because the news posts and pageviews are back. Facebook is even attempting to maintain the flow and quality of news by allowing users to rate news sources and adding context around news posts.

Election years are a boon to media advertising, and Facebook is no exception — though its advertising capabilities provide functions that differ from those of traditional media. Where traditional media offers broad granularity of audiences and some level of accountability. Facebook encourages tight microtargeting and the ability to target specific audiences, which the 2016 Trump campaign deployed with Cambridge Analytica.

For this election cycle, Facebook started with forced ad labeling, but now only three weeks before the midterms, Facebook is starting to clamp down on these microtargeted “dark ads.” There are reports that Facebook did in fact consider banning all political advertising, but did not because the ads reportedly compose a significant amount of revenue, however less than 5% of overall ad revenue according to Reuters.

Attempts for new types of content have failed

A third reason is that attempts for new types of content have failed. A lot of Facebook’s early traction was in addictive social gaming that began to fall off of a cliff as users tired of the games. Since then, Facebook has cast about for new products that can maintain viral loops. There’s a litany of attempted product offerings including Deals, Gifts, Marketplace, Gaming Video, Pintrest-like Sets, etc.

Facebook is even attempting to go up against YouTube with a comprehensive premium video platform for advertisers. However, the end user experience is inferior and overmonetized. For example, viewing a video in full screen mode takes the viewer to a landing page that features other videos, there are painfully inserted midroll ads and another video starts automatically after finishing the first one. It provides a seriously a subpar user experience that attempts to extract every last cent out of a user — reminiscent of Yahoo! towards its bitter end.

Facebook’s biggest problem as it tries to broach new markets is that its continual user account breaches and the founding “move fast and break things” ethos has left users with little trust. As Facebook tries to enter lucrative new markets like online dating, it has to convince its users to share even more intimate details about their lives.

Onwards to thoroughly monetizing the acquisitions

Facebook is starting to recognize that meaningful posting is increasingly taking place on its acquired properties such as Instagram and Whatsapp. These properties are all growing fast and have very constrained posting, such as Snapchat-inspired “stories,” which are hard to algorithmically game. Whether story-style posting can be backported into the core Facebook property remains to be seen — but it appears that Facebook may be using political advertisements as a revenue bridge as it begins to monetize Instagram and Whatsapp.

Thoroughly monetizing Instagram and WhatsApp, however, would require significant changes. Brian Acton, the founder of WhatsApp, says he left due to disagreements with Facebook about ads and the user analytics that power ads. Kevin Systrom, the founder of Instagram, won’t say why he recently left Facebook. However, Systrom is well known for product purity, and the ad load on Instagram has spiked.

In the meantime, Facebook will continue to monetize political posts, even if it’s to our national detriment. I’ll be posting this article to my Facebook feed.




carpoolers said...

Excellent Post...I must thank you for this informative news....This is my first time go to see at here and i am really pleasant to read
all at one place. Housekeeping services companies list, professional housekeeping services in Mumbai, Affordable, Best housekeeping services in Mumbai @ housekeeping services in Mumbai

Indian Packers and Movers said...

Thanks for sharing this Post, Keep Updating such topics. Packers and Movers in Mumbai @ Movers and Packers in Mumbai

eros rosita said...

I hope you can receive information from us.

Apakah Penyakit Gondok Beracun Bisa Menular

Syaraf Kejepit Di Pinggang

Pasti Bisaul said...

I’m amazed by the details that you have on this site.
Gejala Kerusakan Saraf Tepi
Penyebab Nyeri Tulang Belakang Bagian Bawah
Penyebab Sendi Kaku dan Sulit Digerakkan

Pasti Bisaul said...

This site is really cool. I have bookmarked it.
Terapi Pengobatan Penyakit Asma
Pengobatan Penyakit Asam Urat
Pengobatan Infeksi Paru Paru
Cara Menghilangkan Benjolan Di Bawah Ketiak
Pengobatan Alami Pterygium
Cara Mengatasi Penurunan Fungsi Penglihatan

eros rosita said...

I got a page from my friend, thank you for the very useful information.

pantangan makanan penderita infeksi ginjal
makanan yang baik untuk penderita infeksi ginjal

nabila widianti said...

nice from information, i'm very like and thank you for sharing
Cara Mengempeskan Dan Menghilangkan Benjolan Di Kelopak Mata Atas,
Cara Mengobati Kista Rongga Mulut Tanpa Operasi, cara mengobati keratosis pilaris secara alami

Walatra Herbal said...

information that is very much awaited.
Cara Menyembuhkan Bronkopneumonis Secara Alami

eros rosita said...

Your article is truly amazing, hopefully it will progress.

Gejala Syaraf Kejepit
Gejala Osteoporosis
Ciri Ciri Tb Kelenjar

eros rosita said...

sharing is a very good thing, hopefully it can continue.

Menu Diet Bagi Penderita Pembengkakan Hati
Penyebab Pembengkakan Hati

Lutfi Kurniawan said...

The poor do not grieve and do not regret themselves, the rich do not be proud. The degree of humans on the side of God is not because of the wealth of human beings on the side of God just because of their fear

Cara Mengatasi Beser
Obat Vitiligo
Cara Mengatasi Nyeri Pundak
Cara Mengobati Parotitis
Cara Mengatasi Sakit Pinggang

eros rosita said...

Thank you for allowing me to share information in your article.

buah-buahan untuk penderita pengerasan hati
gejala dan pencegahan pengerasan hati

Hepatitis said...

Belief in the coming of success is not sufficient if not accompanied by effort and hard work
Cara Mengatasi Keputihan Akibat Bakteri dan Jamur

eros rosita said...

A healthy lifestyle is the main thing we must guard.

pengaruh tumor rahim pada kehamilan
pantangan makanan untuk penderita tumor rahim

eros rosita said...

The information you submit is very useful.

Gejala Tumor Tulang Pada Anak
Pencegahan dan Pengobatan Tumor Tulang

eros rosita said...

The information you submit is very useful, hopefully it will be better in the future.

Gejala Tumor Hati Pada Anak
Buah-Buahan Untuk Mencegah Tumor Hati

eros rosita said...

Sharing information is very happy, always like that friend.

Penyebab Osteoporosis Pada Usia Muda
Makanan Yang Dilarang Bagi Penderita Osteoporosis

Rositaaa said...

The article that you created is very useful, hopefully it will be better in the future.

Cara Mengobati Infeksi Lambung Secara Alami

Walatra Herbal said...

The presentation of information that you present at noon is very interesting.
Obat Herbal Preeklamsia Untuk Ibu Hamil

Rositaaa said...

Your article is good, hopefully it can work well together.
Obat Herbal Infeksi Rahim

Rositaaa said...

I like the information you submit, hopefully it's better again.
Ciri Ciri Pengerasan Hati

eros rosita said...

Thank you for your cooperation, hopefully it can pay off.
Biaya Operasi Tumor Rahang

Tandem NZ said...

Thank you for sharing great article to us. We are the best award winning web development company in New Zealand. Please Visit Tandem NZ

Rositaaa said...

Sharing information is beautiful. Thank you for an interesting article discussion
Gejala Tumor Otak Pada Remaja
Ciri Ciri Tumor Colli Dextra
Gejala Tumor Hati

Walatra Herbal said...

A presentation of information that is worth visiting.
Gejala Kanker Tulang

Packers Movers Chennai said...

Packers and Movers Chennai Give Safe and Reliable ***Household Shifting Services in Chennai with Reasonable ###Packers and Movers Price Quotation. We Provide Household Shifting, Office Relocation, ✔✔✔Local and Domestic Transportation Services, Affordable and Reliable Shifting Service Charges @
Packers And Movers Chennai

Rositaaa said...

I really like your article, hopefully you can share other interesting information.

Penyebab Nyeri Perut Saat Menstruasi
Cara Mengatasi Hidung Tersumbat dan Meler

Rositaaa said...

Good article to read. Also visit our website at:
Penyebab Tumor Colli Dextra

Eros Rosita said...

Your article is very interesting. Also visit our website at:

Makanan Sehat Untuk Penderita Pembengkakan Hati
Pantangan Makanan Bagi Penderita Pengerasan Hati
Tanaman Obat Untuk Tumor Rahim

walatraherbal07 said...

The information you submit is very useful, hopefully in the future it can provide more information than this.
Kanker Tulang Belakang

Eros Rosita said...

Your article is really interesting. Also visit our website at:

Tanaman Obat Pembengkakan Hati
Jenis Susu Untuk Penderita Pengerasan Hati

Rositaaa said...

Healthy is expensive. So, prioritize your health.

Bahaya Pembengkakan Hati
Ciri Ciri Pengerasan Hati

Eros Rosita said...

Because it is actually healthy, then stress your health before various diseases attack.
Cara Mengobati Tumor Tulang

Rositaaa said...

do you like fishing? let's see our website.

Essen Ikan Mas Babon Galatama

ipsworkforce said...

Hai, If your career will be in politics or you want to grow your skills in political path, I think this company will give the right way.
Online masters in political science india,
Career as a politician in india
Election management courses in india

evs group said...

Thanks for your blog. If you want political consulting services and political career path for your needs, here the company will be the right place.
Election Consultant India
How to start political career in india
Political communication courses

Rositaaa said...

For those of you who like fishing, visit our website at:

Essen Ikan Mas Galatama Musim Hujan

Eros Rosita said...

Your article is very interesting

Essen Ikan Lele Babon

Barracuda Essen said...

Your article is very interesting. Also visit our website at:

Eros Rosita said...

The information you provide is very petrified, hopefully it can provide better.
Essen Ikan Mas Harian Terbaik

Rositaaa said...

Thank you for the cooperation that has been established.

Umpan Ikan Mas Sederhana

Eros Rosita said...

The information you submit is very helpful, thank you.

Umpan Ikan Lele Dumbo Galatama

Rositaaa said...

If you like fishing, visit our website:

Oplosan Essen Ikan Mas Kilo Gebrus

Eros Rosita said...

Are you looking for the best tilapia essen? Click on the link below :

Oplosan Essen Ikan Nila Paling Jitu

neha mumbai escorts said...

Welcome to home of the finest Mumbai escorts in Mumbai area. Our Mumbai escorts are the finest Mumbai has to offer and will provide an unforgettable Mumbai Escort experience!
Escorts in mumbai
Escort service in mumbai
Mumbai escorts
Mumbai call girls
Call girls in mumbai
Escorts mumbai
Mumbai escorts services
Gurgaon escorts
Independents mumbai escorts
Mumbai escorts independents
Mumbai Escorts services
Escort service in mumbai
Escorts in delhi
Escort service in delhi
delhi escorts service

Rositaaa said...

Your article is very useful, hopefully the future posts can be even better.

Cara Mancing Ikan Nila Susah Makan

Eros Rosita said...

If you like fishing for catfish, visit our website at:

Essen Ikan Patin Kolam Harian

Eros Rosita said...

I found this page from Google. Thanks

Umpan Ikan Mas Garung